Peacock Blog Peacock

What Candiace Said Colton Told Her About Rob on The Traitors

Was there a conspiracy happening inside The Traitors castle?

By Tara Bennett
A split featuring Colton Underwood and Candiace Dillard Bassett.

SPOILER WARNING: This story reveals major plot points from Episodes 1-11 of The Traitors Season 4.

How to Watch

Stream The Traitors Thursdays at 9/8c exclusively on Peacock.

Unfinished business was the subtext that permeated the majority of The Traitors Season 4 Reunion Show hosted by Andy Cohen

Be it Rob Rausch and Maura Higginsovert chemistry, and subsequent betrayal on Rob's part, Natalie Anderson's lingering anger over Tara Lipinski folding in the face of a Rob Elimination vote, or why Lisa Rinna would choose to wear the murder in plain sight brooch at the banquet, there was plenty to discuss amongst the whole cast.

But one of the biggest confrontations/revelations to come to the surface during the Reunion Special was former Traitor Candiace Dillard Bassett's confrontation with Rob. She point blank floated that his Faithful ally Colton Underwood told her something in confidence which backed up her "snake" assessment of fellow Traitor Rob. 

Find out below.

RELATED: Who Won The Traitors Season 4? The Shocking Results Revealed

The cast sits at a round table on The Traitors Episode 404. 

What did Colton allegedly tell Candiace during The Traitors?

During the reunuon, Candiace said to Rob, and then to Colton, that Colton had shared with her that Rob was a Traitor. 

RELATED: Everyone Who's Been Murdered or Banished on The Traitors, So Far (SPOILERS)

"You said to me that Rob told you that I was a Traitor," she said.

Rob was initially confused and then denied that he told Colton anything of the sort. He brought up the strict rules of the show and said he abided by them. Colton was more specific in his rebuttal and said that he trusted Rob as an ally implicitly while they played the game.

"It's no secret that Rob and I were working together. I 100% thought I was working with another faithful, so I'll just put that out. Rob and I bounced names off of each other, I trusted him a lot, and Lisa was still in the game. I said, 'Hey, we're getting Lisa out 100%," he said, 'Yes.' I said, 'Alright, next up is Candiace."

Since Colton was an aggressive player, he was more vocal about strategy and Rob took a quieter approach which worked until Colton was "Murdered" in Episode 8. He was equally adamant that he played with "integrity and would not cheat" which Candiace didn't refute. In fact, Colton said he played so aggressively because he wanted to be recruited as a Traitor and he was playing so hard to try to get to that turning point in the game.  

Stream The Traitors Season 4 exclusively on Peacock.