Peacock Blog Peacock

How The Traitors Managed to Murder This Player in Plain Sight (RECAP)

If you're in the mood for spoilers, find out who fell victim to the second murder of Season 4.

By Tara Bennett
Alan Cumming wears an all-black outfit on The Traitors Season 4 Episode 1.

SPOILER WARNING: This story reveals major plot points from Episodes 1-3 of The Traitors Season 4.

There's no rest for the weary Traitors in the already tension-filled first three episodes of Peacock's The TraitorSeason 4 (now available for streaming on Peacock). Host Alan Cumming is making his devilish Traitor minions work hard for their potential spoils of $250,000 by adding a Secret Traitor twist and disrupting the typical structure of the game days. 

How to Watch

Stream The Traitors Thursdays at 9/8c exclusively on Peacock.

RELATED: Everything to Know About Peacock's The Traitors Season 4 (DETAILS)

In particular, at the end of the second episode, Traitors Candiace Dillard Bassett, Rob Rausch, and Lisa Rinna are put on the spot and tasked with an infamous Traitor stress-inducer: A murder in plain sight. The special task asked of the Traitors not only ensures the successful completion of a Faithful "Murder" but in this case, it promised a much-wanted reward for the trio. 

Find out all the details below.

What is a "murder in plain sight" on The Traitors?

The idea of the Traitors being tasked to commit a Faithful "Murder" outside of the castle turret was first introduced in The Traitors during Season 2 in the third episode, "Murder in Plain Sight." After that episode's Roundtable, Traitors Dan Gheesling, Phaedra Parks, and Parvati Shallow received a letter from Alan that said one of them would have to give a "poisoned" chalice to a Faithful of their choice before the evening curfew or there would be no "Murder" the next morning.

The cast of The Traitors gather around a giant round table on Episode 401

The next time it appeared was in the fourth episode of Season 3, "I Will Bury You Under the Sand." Traitors Boston Rob, Danielle Reyes, Bob The Drag Queen and Carolyn Wiger were given a letter that tasked them with putting the names of three players into mini coffins right under the noses of the Faithfuls roaming in the castle.

Who accomplishes the "murder in plain sight" during The Traitors Season 4?

After the Roundtable in the second episode, the Traitors are given individual letters that task them with finding a set of hidden tarot cards behind a picture in the kitchen. They are to retrieve them, review the four Faithful players on the cards, select one to be "Murdered," and then burn that card in the fireplace while all of the Faithful players are still mingling in the castle after the vote. 

Unable to get together to discuss a shared strategy, Candiace takes it upon herself to start an impromptu conga line with Lisa in the kitchen. All but two players are game to play along with the boisterous ladies: Rob R. and Rob Cesternino. Rob R. doesn't join because he uses the distraction to slip away, find the cards behind the Reaper picture in the kitchen and quickly review them.

A split of Rob Rausch, Lisa Rinna, and Candiace Dillard Bassett for The Traitors Season 4.

Meanwhile, Rob C. is suspicious about the conga line. He believes the Traitors are up to no good and that it's likely that a murder in plain sight is being executed right under everybody's noses. He darts around the castle ground floor looking for suspects.

Who was murdered in plain sight?

When the dance is over, Candiace sees Rob C. and he tells her his theory which puts her even more on edge. Meanwhile, Rob R. and Lisa sit down at the chess table to cover their coded conversation about their "Murder" options: Tara Lipinski, Kristen Kish, Monét X Change, or Rob C. With no way to add Candiace to their conversation, they make the call that Rob C. should go. 

Rob Cesternino sitting in a library wearing a jacket and orange tee smiling during The Traitors

Rob R. heads to the fireplace and manages to burn Rob C.'s tarot card with a candle and then throw the rest into the fireplace without being caught. It's a masterclass of execution by all three, but Rob R. remains cool as a cucumber as he accomplishes the hardest elements of the task. Their success ensures a successful "Murder" of their choice, but also the promised reveal of the Secret Traitor on the following day of play.

Check out what Rob C. has to say about his ousting in the latest episode of The Traitors Official Podcast.

The Traitors Season 4 Ultimate Fan Guide

With Season 4's treachery and deception officially a go amongst the 23 celeb contestants under Alan Cumming's watchful eye, it's time for fans to lock-in. For eight weeks, the Faithful and the Traitors will complete thrilling missions to win a prize of up to $250,000. Luckily, throughout the shocking season, there will be plenty of opportunities for The Traitors viewers to dive deep into the fandom when you're not streaming episodes on Peacock.

Below, the ultimate fan guide that will keep you entertained and in-the-know throughout Season 4:

Peacock Exclusives 

  • Check out the Can't Miss Clips Traitors Playlist featured exclusively on The Peacock Mobile App that drops new trailers and scenes from the episode every Monday and Friday. 
  • Don’t miss the Can't Miss Clips Traitors Podcast Playlist featured exclusively on The Peacock Mobile App updated every Saturday. 
  • Play The Traitors Prediction Game available exclusively on The Peacock Mobile App under Mini-Games Today. Every Tuesday, take a quiz to make your predictions about what's to come for the week's episode, with answers revealed on Fridays. 

Beyond the Episode and IRL 

  • Launching January 8, don’t miss The Traitors Official Podcast, hosted by Season 3 Traitor alumni Boston Rob and Bob the Drag Queen, who will recap every episode each Thursday and provide expert perspectives and interview special guests. 
  • The Traitors x Black Tap Watch Parties taking place throughout the season at Black Tap locations in New York City, Nashville, Dallas, and Vegas on January 8 and 29, and February 26. 

  • From January 14 to 22, head to Peacock's The Traitors Immersive Fan Experience in New York City, an immersive competitive game that invites both Traitors and Faithfuls to take part in a series of heart-stopping missions full of trickery, strategy and suspense set inside a storied 1875 Brooklyn landmark. 

Stream The Traitors every Thursday at 6pm PT/9pm ET, exclusively on Peacock.